By Advocate Karan Dua | Vintage Litigation, New Delhi
Divorce Under Article 142 is an extraordinary legal remedy that allows the Supreme Court of India to dissolve a marriage that has broken down beyond repair, even when one spouse refuses to agree to the divorce. This constitutional power helps couples facing prolonged separation, failed reconciliation and years of matrimonial litigation seek a final resolution in appropriate cases.
A marriage that has broken down beyond repair can create years of legal disputes. Sometimes, couples spend more time fighting in court than they spent living together. But can the Supreme Court of India grant a divorce even when one spouse refuses to agree?
Yes. Divorce Under Article 142 gives the Supreme Court extraordinary constitutional powers to dissolve a marriage in appropriate cases. The Court can exercise this power when it finds that the marriage has completely broken down and that ending it would serve the interests of justice.
For couples facing prolonged matrimonial disputes, this power offers an important legal remedy. However, Article 142 does not provide a shortcut to divorce. The Supreme Court exercises it carefully and considers the complete circumstances of each case.
This article explains Article 142 divorce, important Supreme Court judgments, legal requirements and practical options for couples in Delhi.
What Is Divorce Under Article 142 of the Constitution?
Article 142(1) of the Indian Constitution empowers the Supreme Court to pass orders necessary to do complete justice in any matter pending before it.
In matrimonial disputes, the Supreme Court can use this constitutional power to dissolve a marriage that has broken down beyond repair.
The Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, does not recognise irretrievable breakdown of marriage as an independent ground for divorce under Section 13. Therefore, Family Courts cannot grant divorce solely because the relationship has ended emotionally.
Instead, couples generally need to establish a statutory ground, such as cruelty or desertion, or file a mutual consent divorce petition under Section 13B.
However, the Supreme Court holds a special constitutional power under Article 142. In appropriate cases, it can dissolve a marriage even when one spouse strongly opposes the divorce.
You can read more about this constitutional power in this Legal Service India article on Article 142 divorce.
Supreme Court Constitution Bench Judgment: Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan (2023)
The Supreme Court clarified the scope of Article 142 in May 2023 through its five-judge Constitution Bench judgment in Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan (2023 INSC 468).
The Bench confirmed that the Supreme Court can dissolve a marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown, even without the consent of both spouses.
The judgment also explained that the Court must consider several circumstances before exercising this power.
These include:
- How long the couple lived together.
- How many years they have lived separately.
- Whether the marriage has any realistic chance of reconciliation.
- The nature of disputes and allegations between the spouses.
- The number and nature of pending court proceedings.
- Previous mediation and settlement attempts.
- Financial arrangements, maintenance and alimony.
- The interests and welfare of children.
The Constitution Bench also discussed separation of around six years or more as a relevant consideration. However, it did not establish six years as a compulsory requirement.
Every matrimonial dispute has different facts. Therefore, the Supreme Court examines the complete circumstances before granting relief.
January 2026 Supreme Court Judgment: Neha Lal v. Abhishek Kumar
The Supreme Court’s decision in Neha Lal v. Abhishek Kumar (2026 INSC 73), decided on 20 January 2026, provides an important example of Article 142 in practice.
The couple married in January 2012 but lived together for approximately 65 days. They subsequently remained separated for more than ten years and became involved in over forty legal proceedings.
The dispute eventually reached the Supreme Court through a transfer petition.
During the proceedings, the wife requested divorce under Article 142. The husband opposed her request and raised allegations of false cases and perjury. Mediation also failed to resolve their differences.
After examining the circumstances, the Supreme Court concluded that the marriage had broken down beyond repair.
The Court dissolved the marriage despite the husband’s objection and disposed of the pending matrimonial disputes between the parties. However, it allowed the perjury proceedings to continue because those proceedings involved the administration of justice.
You can read the Neha Lal judgment on Indian Kanoon.
This judgment makes one point clear: a spouse cannot automatically prevent an Article 142 divorce simply by refusing consent.
Other Important Supreme Court Article 142 Divorce Cases in 2026
The Supreme Court also considered Article 142 in other matrimonial disputes during 2026.
In Kishorekumar Mohan Kale v. Kashmira Kale, the Court refused to recognise a US divorce decree because of the jurisdictional circumstances involved. It subsequently exercised Article 142 to dissolve the marriage after noting that the NRI couple had lived separately since 2008.
This decision highlights the importance of understanding foreign divorce judgments and their recognition in India. Couples dealing with international matrimonial disputes can also explore our guide on NRI divorce in India.
Another important decision came in Dhananjay Rathi v. Ruchika Rathi (2026 INSC 360), decided on 13 April 2026.
The couple had reached a settlement during mediation. However, the wife later withdrew her consent before the second motion and initiated domestic violence proceedings.
The Supreme Court exercised Article 142 to grant divorce, quashed the domestic violence proceedings in the circumstances of the settlement and directed payment of the remaining alimony.
Read the Supreme Court judgment in Dhananjay Rathi.
These decisions demonstrate that the Supreme Court considers the facts, settlement history and legal consequences of each matrimonial dispute separately.
Can You File a Divorce Petition Directly Under Article 142?
No. A person cannot approach the Supreme Court with a fresh petition seeking divorce solely under Article 142.
The Supreme Court can exercise this power only in a matter properly pending before it.
Generally, a matrimonial dispute may begin in the Family Court, proceed to the High Court and eventually reach the Supreme Court through an appeal or Special Leave Petition.
A genuine transfer petition may also bring a matrimonial dispute before the Supreme Court, as happened in Neha Lal v. Abhishek Kumar.
However, couples should not file unnecessary proceedings merely to bring their dispute before the Supreme Court. Article 142 remains an extraordinary constitutional remedy, not an alternative filing procedure.
What Factors Does the Supreme Court Consider Before Granting Divorce?
The Supreme Court examines the complete matrimonial history before deciding whether a marriage has irretrievably broken down.
Duration of separation: Long separation may indicate that reconciliation has become unrealistic. However, the Court does not follow a fixed minimum period.
Duration of marriage: Judges consider how long the spouses lived together before separation. A brief marriage followed by years of litigation may present different circumstances from a long marriage with a recent dispute.
Pending litigation: Multiple matrimonial, criminal, maintenance and civil proceedings may help the Court understand the depth of the conflict.
Failed mediation: Genuine settlement attempts matter. Repeated failures may indicate that the parties cannot restore their relationship.
Conduct of both spouses: The Court may examine maintenance payments, financial disclosures, compliance with previous orders and other relevant conduct.
Financial and family responsibilities: Judges also consider alimony, permanent maintenance, child custody and the future welfare of children.
Therefore, anyone seeking Article 142 relief should prepare a clear record of the matrimonial history and present a practical settlement proposal wherever appropriate.
Alimony, Maintenance and Child Custody Under Article 142
Divorce does not end every financial and parental responsibility between spouses.
The Supreme Court considers financial fairness while exercising Article 142. It may examine income, assets, liabilities, maintenance obligations and the financial needs of both parties.
A spouse seeking divorce should prepare an appropriate financial proposal. The Court may consider permanent alimony or other settlement terms before passing its final order.
Our guides on maintenance law in India and bank transactions in maintenance cases explain these financial issues in greater detail.
Children require separate consideration. The Court must protect their welfare and may address custody or leave detailed arrangements to the appropriate forum.
Read our guide on child custody laws in India to understand parental rights and child welfare considerations.
Does Article 142 Divorce Automatically Close Criminal and Domestic Violence Cases?
No. The Supreme Court does not automatically close every pending case when it dissolves a marriage.
The Court examines each proceeding separately.
For example, in Dhananjay Rathi v. Ruchika Rathi, the Supreme Court quashed domestic violence proceedings in the context of the settlement.
However, in Neha Lal v. Abhishek Kumar, the Court allowed perjury proceedings to continue.
This distinction is important. A divorce decree ends the marital relationship, but it does not automatically remove every legal consequence arising from earlier conduct.
If you face domestic violence or other criminal proceedings alongside matrimonial litigation, consult a lawyer before entering into a settlement.
You can also read our detailed guide on domestic violence cases in India.
What Should You Do If You Want a Divorce but Your Spouse Refuses?
A spouse’s refusal does not automatically prevent every legal route to divorce.
First, understand whether your spouse may consider a mutual settlement. Mutual consent divorce under Section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act provides a structured route when both parties agree.
If your spouse refuses consent, you may consider a contested divorce petition based on legally recognised grounds, such as cruelty or desertion.
Delhi couples can explore our guides on mutual consent divorce and contested divorce in India.
Maintain copies of relevant court orders, mediation records, financial documents and communications. A clear chronology will help your lawyer understand the dispute and identify the appropriate legal remedy.
Do not assume that Article 142 will automatically apply to your case. The Supreme Court decides each application on its own facts.
What If Your Spouse Seeks Divorce Under Article 142 and You Oppose It?
You still have the right to present your position before the Supreme Court.
You can explain why reconciliation may remain possible, identify genuine settlement opportunities and bring relevant facts to the Court’s attention.
You can also raise concerns about unpaid maintenance, financial arrangements, child custody and compliance with previous court orders.
However, simply refusing consent may not prevent the Supreme Court from dissolving the marriage.
The Court considers the overall circumstances rather than treating one spouse’s objection as an absolute veto.
Both spouses should focus on presenting accurate facts and seeking fair legal and financial outcomes.
Article 142 Divorce for Couples in Delhi: Which Court Should You Approach?
Most matrimonial disputes in Delhi begin before the appropriate Family Court, depending on jurisdiction and the facts of the case.
Delhi has several court complexes that handle matrimonial matters, including:
- Saket Family Court
- Dwarka Court
- Rohini Court
- Karkardooma Court
- Patiala House Court
- Tis Hazari Courts
Depending on the nature of the dispute, an appeal may proceed before the Delhi High Court.
Only matters that properly reach the Supreme Court can attract its extraordinary Article 142 jurisdiction.
Frequently Asked Questions About Divorce Under Article 142
Can the Supreme Court grant divorce without the consent of both spouses?
Yes. The Supreme Court can dissolve a marriage under Article 142 even when one spouse opposes the divorce, provided the circumstances justify the exercise of this extraordinary power.
Is irretrievable breakdown a ground for divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act?
No. The Hindu Marriage Act does not independently recognise irretrievable breakdown as a statutory ground. However, the Supreme Court can grant relief under Article 142 in appropriate cases.
How many years of separation are necessary for Article 142 divorce?
There is no fixed minimum period. The Supreme Court considers the duration of separation along with other relevant circumstances.
Can a Family Court grant divorce under Article 142?
No. Article 142 gives this extraordinary constitutional power to the Supreme Court, not Family Courts or High Courts.
Does Article 142 automatically cancel maintenance?
No. The Court considers financial obligations and settlement terms separately. Existing maintenance orders do not automatically disappear merely because the marriage ends.
Can the Supreme Court close a 498A or domestic violence case while granting divorce?
The Supreme Court may pass appropriate orders in connected proceedings, depending on the facts and applicable law. However, divorce does not automatically terminate every criminal proceeding.
Can an NRI couple obtain divorce under Article 142?
The Supreme Court may exercise Article 142 in an appropriate matrimonial matter pending before it. The Court considers jurisdiction, applicable law and the circumstances of the dispute.
Is Article 142 divorce guaranteed after six years of separation?
No. Six years is not an automatic eligibility rule. The Supreme Court examines the complete facts before granting relief.
Conclusion: Understand Your Legal Options Before Seeking Article 142 Divorce
Divorce Under Article 142 gives the Supreme Court extraordinary constitutional authority to dissolve marriages that have broken down beyond repair. It can grant relief even when one spouse refuses consent.
However, this remedy remains exceptional. Couples cannot approach the Supreme Court directly with a fresh Article 142 divorce petition. The Court must already have a matter properly before it.
For couples in Delhi, the practical approach is to understand the available remedies under the Hindu Marriage Act, maintain proper legal records and seek appropriate advice before choosing a course of action.
If you are facing prolonged matrimonial litigation, contested divorce, maintenance disputes or child custody issues, consult an experienced matrimonial lawyer to understand your legal options.
Advocate Karan Dua | Vintage Litigation, New Delhi
Consult our matrimonial lawyers in Delhi for guidance on divorce proceedings, matrimonial disputes and related legal remedies.
Disclaimer: This article provides general legal information and does not constitute legal advice. The outcome of every matrimonial dispute depends on its facts, evidence and applicable law. Consult a qualified lawyer before taking legal action.
